"Firing squad execution underscores inhumanity of death penalty," is the title of Richard Dieter's commentary at Jurist. He's the Executive Director of the Death Penalty Information Center.
Gardner got the kind of execution he wanted--death by firing squad--and Utah finally got what it wanted--retribution for the murder Gardner had committed twenty-five years ago. We the people (and in this case, there was a worldwide audience) probably scratched our heads wondering what that was all about.
And:
But while the firing squad is clearly on the way out, executions by lethal injection continue under a cloak of antiseptic obscurity. The death penalty is winding down, as overwhelming evidence in this country and around the world demonstrates. Death sentences, executions, and the number of states with the death penalty have dropped sharply in the past decade. The U.S. is now one of a very small number of countries to carry out executions annually. The strong stream of progress in human rights implies that capital punishment itself will eventually be relegated to the same history as slavery, apartheid, and torture. Even as vestiges of these practices remain, they are clearly condemned in the world community. We continue to execute people in this country not because such actions are necessary but because we have not yet figured out how to extricate ourselves from this practice. In the meantime, people like Ronnie Gardner are chosen from among thousands on death row and killed because their number has come up. Occasionally they "go out in a blaze of glory," but as retiring Justice John Paul Stevens recently concluded, it is the pointless and needless extinction of life."
More commentary on the Gardner execution begins with this post.
Comments