"Should Davis be executed? No: Questions about his guilt continue to plague his conviction," is the title of William S. Sessions' OpEd in today's Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
In 2007, the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles issued a stay of execution for Davis and took the admirable position that it would “not allow an execution to proceed in this State unless and until its members are convinced that there is no doubt as to the guilt of the accused.”
Because this case continues to be permeated by doubt, the Board of Pardons and Paroles’ stance continues to be the right one. In reality, there will always be cases, including capital cases, in which doubts about guilt cannot be erased to an acceptable level of certainty. The Davis case is one of these, and it is for cases like this that executive clemency exists.
Those responsible for clemency play a vital role in ensuring our legal system includes a measure of compassion and humanity. The death penalty should not be carried out, and Davis’ sentence should be commuted to life.Democracy Now! host Amy Goodman's latest syndicated column is, "Troy Davis, victim of judicial lynching; Troy Davis faces execution on 21 September, despite seven of nine non-police witnesses recanting. Where is the justice in that?" It's via the Guardian.
In the most recent Republican presidential debate in Tampa, Florida, when CNN's Wolf Blitzer asked, hypothetically, if a man who chose to carry no medical insurance, then was stricken with a grave illness, should be left to die, cheers of "Yeah!" filled the hall. When, in the prior debate, Governor Rick Perry was asked about his enthusiastic use of the death penalty in Texas, the crowd erupted into sustained applause and cheers. The reaction from the audience prompted debate moderator Brian Williams of NBC News to follow up with the question, "What do you make of that dynamic that just happened here, the mention of the execution of 234 people drew applause?"
That "dynamic" is why challenging the death sentence to be carried out against Troy Davis by the state of Georgia on 21 September is so important. Davis has been on Georgia's death row for close to 20 years, after being convicted of killing off-duty police officer Mark MacPhail in Savannah. Since his conviction, seven of the nine non-police witnesses have recanted their testimony, alleging police coercion and intimidation in obtaining the testimony. There is no physical evidence linking Davis to the murder.
Last March, the US supreme court ruled that Davis should receive an evidentiary hearing, to make his case for innocence. Several witnesses have identified one of the remaining witnesses who has not recanted, Sylvester "Redd" Coles, as the shooter. US District Judge William T Moore Jr refused, on a technicality, to allow the testimony of witnesses who claimed that, after Davis had been convicted, Coles admitted to shooting MacPhail. In his August court order, Moore summarised, "Mr Davis is not innocent."
One of the jurors, Brenda Forrest, disagrees. She told CNN in 2009, recalling the trial of Davis, "All of the witnesses – they were able to ID him as the person who actually did it." Since the seven witnesses recanted, she says: "If I knew then what I know now, Troy Davis would not be on death row. The verdict would be not guilty."
Today, supporters of Troy Davis submitted well over 600,000 petition signature calling for clemency.
USA Today reports, "Ga. death-row case shows power of social media." It's written by Melanie Eversley.
A social media campaign to stop an execution in Georgia next week is drawing support from hundreds of thousands of people around the world.
Celebrities, Nobel laureates and national leaders have joined the NAACP, Amnesty International and the grassroots group Change.org to urge Georgia authorities to grant clemency to Troy Davis, who is scheduled to die by lethal injection Wednesday. They are flooding Twitter with several tweets a minute, signing online petitions and, starting today, planning to rally around the country.
And:
The latest effort, triggered when a new execution date was set last week, includes celebrities John Legend, Mia Farrow and the Indigo Girls. All are tweeting under #TooMuchDoubt, a search term devised by Amnesty International and the NAACP. Davis supporters also have created Facebook pages.
"In the moment, when our nation stumbles toward complete failure of its justice system, we have to give every citizen the opportunity to express their outrage and their intention that the state not do this in their name," NAACP President Benjamin Todd Jealous says. "When the state executes an innocent person, every citizen is implicated in that act."
The tweets ask the public to contact the Georgia State Board of Pardons and Paroles — the group with the authority to halt Davis' death — and to urge the panel to grant clemency. They also ask people to sign one of three petitions the groups are circulating online.
"I think the key thing we are trying to express to the Georgia authorities is there are just so many doubts," says Laura Moye, death penalty abolition campaign director for Amnesty International USA.
The board is scheduled to meet Monday to consider the case. If it does not grant clemency, there is no official next legal step, but "we are not going to stand by quietly if that is what happens," Moye says. The NAACP also is calling on Chatham County, Ga., District Attorney Larry Chisolm to move to withdraw the death warrant, Jealous says.
Representatives from Amnesty International and the NAACP presented four petitions with more than 600,000 signatures to the state parole board Thursday. An online petition sponsored by Davis' sister, Kimberly Davis, and Change.org has collected more than 233,000 signatures.
This is what more than 650,000 petition signatures look like.
Troy Davis' case has caught the attention of people around the world. Alice Kim, Director of the Public Square at the Illinois Humanities Council, is no stranger to the issue of capital punishment. She's worked tirelessly to keep Illinois exonerees connected and to provide forums for them to bear witness. At her Dancing the Dialectic blog, she's posted, "'I need a poem' for Troy Davis." Here's a brief excerpt:
"I need a poem, need a poem, a master poem, once and for all, I need a poem to destroy poetry and break these iron bars." I fall in love with these words every time I read them, words written by exonerated death row prisoner and poet Delbert Tibbs. Today, I repeat these words for Troy Davis.
I want there to be a poem so powerful, so magical, so momentous that it can save Troy's life. He is scheduled to be executed thirteen days from today on Wednesday, September 21 at 7pm in Georgia. It is possible that these next thirteen days will be his last. If business as usual is not interrupted then a legal lynching will take place. But Troy has survived three previous execution dates because of doubts about his guilt, and I want to hope that Troy will be spared from execution a fourth time, that the power of the people will be the poetry that can save his life.
It seems that her post is, at least partially, inspired by Delbert Tibbs' "I Need a Poem." Delbert Tibbs' story is told in the play, "The Exonerated;" he's the anchor of the play. He was exonerated from death row in Florida and lives in Chicago. He's a national treasure. Everyone should get to hear Delbert speak his poetry.
Earlier coverage of Troy Davis' case begins at the link.
Comments